French Farmers Mobilize as Controversial Agriculture Bill Ignites Political Clash

On Monday, hundreds of farmers converged on Paris, steering their tractors right up to the doors of the French National Assembly, carrying not just farm equipment but also palpable irritation.

Their aim was to back a contentious bill proposed by far-right politician Laurent Duplomb.

The Duplomb agriculture bill aims to alleviate what numerous people in the farming sector perceive as oppressive regulations. administrative constraints.

It would make it easier to obtain construction permits for livestock facilities and water reservoirs, and re-authorise the temporary use of certain pesticides such as acetamiprid; a neonicotinoid insecticide banned in France since 2018.

Although permitted in other EU nations, acetamiprid has sparked concerns amongst environmental advocates and beekeepers because of its effects on pollinator species and possible human health hazards.

The legislation was set for discussion, leading to a ballot in the lower chamber of parliament on Monday.

But opposition lawmakers, mostly from the green and left-wing parties , submitted approximately 3,500 amendments in an effort to stall the process.

As debates were hampered by legislative deadlock, centrist, conservative, and far-right politicians approved a measure to avoid discussing the bill in parliament.

The proposition will now be handed over to a combined panel comprising seven senators and seven MPs—most of whom back the farmers' requests.

The committee needs to reach consensus on a unified version which will subsequently undergo a conclusive vote by Members of Parliament—this round, with no opportunity for modifications.

The move has infuriated the left, which has announced plans to file a no-confidence motion against the government in response.

What everyone desires is simply to live and endure

Many of the farmers who attended the demonstration see this legislation as an opportunity to alleviate growing financial and bureaucratic burdens.

Clément Patoir, a 19-year-old grains farmer, explained how excessive bureaucracy is pushing young individuals away from farming.

"There are fewer young people who want to become farmers nowadays. Many children of farmers have to constantly hear about their parents struggling with regulations. It is a complicated job, you work long hours, and you're not necessarily rewarded."

"Most French farmers are struggling to make ends meet. We all aspire to thrive rather than just get by. Therefore, less red tape and more simplicity would be greatly welcomed," said Patoir.

A young sugar beet farmer named Pierrick mentioned that the legislation aims at sustaining current production rates. Many sugar beet and hazelnut growers view the acetamiprid pesticide as crucial.

"Currently, every approach to maximize output is slowly slipping out of our grasp. Moreover, we face bureaucratic hurdles that only pile onto our responsibilities... Yet, to sustain our current level of productivity, there isn’t an effective substitute available right now," he stated.

Proponents of the legislation maintain that relaxing regulations will be essential for preventing dependence on imported goods and maintaining the competitiveness of France's farming industry.

However, environmental advocates and leftist politicians view the legislation as risky. Present among those assembled in Paris to contest this were figures like Gabriel Bertein, a progressive mayor, who cautioned about potential lasting harm to biodiversity and soil quality.

“If such legislation gets approved, it would indicate that we’re moving backward. It opens up avenues for increased usage of pesticide products that we recognize as harmful to living beings,” he stated, facing interruptions from an agitated crowd of farmers.

He mentioned that public money ought to be redirected towards supporting environmentally friendly agricultural methods.

We need to cease supporting and funding a form of intensive farming that isn’t headed in the correct direction. It’s crucial we alter our course promptly and concentrate on these issues.

Protests are also scheduled for next week in Brussels, aimed at the EU’s environmental rules and green policy agenda.

Share :